I Have 22 Journals Written By a Girl Who Committed Suicide


(Trigger warning: rape, suicide, and self-harm are discussed in this post. If these are topics that may cause you to descend into a dark place, please stop reading now.)

I met her parents at a Panera Bread just outside Baltimore to talk about turning their daughter’s life into a book. It was our second meeting. Afterwards we walked out into the parking lot and I went with them to their car. Her mother popped open the trunk and handed me a heavy bag full of journals.

“I’m really nervous about taking this with me,” I said. “I don’t normally take original material from my clients.”

I paused.

“I’ll guard these very closely,” I said.

We stood there, and I stared at the bag, heavy in my hands.

“I know you will,” her mother said. I reached in and took the bag out. i gave her mother a hug with the arm not holding the bag and shook her father’s hand.

“Oh,” she added, “I wouldn’t let your children look at those. They can be rather…dark.”

I nodded.

“See you in a few months,” I said.

* * * * *

They’re in my office now, those journals. They are various sizes and colors, some the typical journals you might buy at a book store, others handmade and decorated with artwork. The girl whose handwriting flows from one year to the next started writing them when she was thirteen years old and continued on until she was twenty.

They seem alive. Sometimes, when I go into my office and close the door, I’ll stare at them, and it’s like they have a pulse. They breathe. Because that is her life, right there, those scribbled words that stretch from page to page. It’s an organism, one that tells over and over again, no matter how many times you read it, the tale of a girl who had a disease we struggle to understand.

There are the stories of the two times she was raped. Her sense of never fitting in at school. Her self-harm. Cutting. There is the story of telling a counselor about her rapes, a few years after the fact. There is the spiraling downward, and the suicide attempts. There are the cries for help, the anguish, the confusion. There is desperation.

There is medication after medication after medication. Treatment. Psychiatric evaluations. Counseling sessions. Times when she seemed to be doing better. Times when she wanted to give up. She called her Depression “The Beast” and “The Imp” and she chronicled her life with these strangers. They were things she couldn’t live with, things she couldn’t live without.

Then there was her final journal entry, when she expressed that within a month all would be well – she would either be better, or she would be dead. And you can tell that there is immense relief, almost joy in that glimpse of the end of the struggle.

There is the last picture she drew, one of her alter ego flying away from the scene of her funeral on colorful wings over a church with stained-glass windows.

Then she walked into a lake, and they found her nine months later.

* * * * *

What can we do for those who walk among us but cannot bear this thing called life?

* * * * *

A friend of mine, Ami, only a few days ago retold the story of her own recent suicide attempt:

I don’t know what made me decide on a Sunday morning in early June to take a palmful of Tylenol before walking out the door to go to church like I do every Sunday. I didn’t wake up that morning knowing that I was going to try to die that day. When I was asked at church if I was planning on doing anything, I didn’t know that I would go home and take another handful of Tylenol.

I don’t know why I took that second overdose.

To those of us who have a loved one battling suicidal thoughts, these words can be scary. We want to know what to do to prevent it. We want to know what we can do to keep this thing from happening.

I don’t know the answer. I don’t think there is “an answer.”

* * * * *

When I was young, suicide was talked about in hushed whispers, the unpardonable sin. The Amish, the community from which my ancestral roots sprang forth, used to bury those who committed suicide on the spot, not even marking the grave. They were forgotten, or at least smoothed over, their history lost in a field beneath the tree where they were found hanging, or outside the barn where their blood was spilled.

Those lucky enough to receive a proper burial were deliberately buried outside the graveyard fence, symbolic of their excommunication from the church, albeit after death.

This is no different than many we hear today who talk about those who commit suicide as being “cowards,.” Such a label erases the person, erases the struggles.

“Selfish,” some will say.

“The most self-centered thing you could ever do.”

But I’ve read twenty-two journals of a girl who could not bear to live, and I do not see a weak person. I do not see a selfish person. I do not see a coward. In fact, she is one of the bravest people I’ve ever had the chance to know – she battled her illness for eight long years. Having read her life and the thoughts that continually went back and forth inside of her head, I don’t think I could have lasted eight years under that kind of torment.

I’m eager to tell you her story so that you can see these things, too. Maybe it will change the way you view this disease. Maybe, like the mud Jesus told the blind man to put on his eyes, her story will help you to see.

* * * * *

This is a long post, but the point I’m trying to make is actually a very short one.

Be kind.

Remember that none of us can comprehend the pain of another person.

Speak well of those who could not bear this life, or do not speak at all.

20 Replies to “I Have 22 Journals Written By a Girl Who Committed Suicide”

    1. Thank you for allowing me to link to your post, Ami. Maybe for now all that any of us can do is sit together quietly in the unknowing.

  1. Shawn,
    Thank you. Thank you for your kindness towards people like me, people who suffer with depression. It was once a topic people wouldn’t talk about, like if they talked about they would become “damaged” to.

  2. thanks for writing this. a lot being said is coming from people with no actual context to write from other than uninformed opinion.

  3. There but for the grace of God. I spent years trying to decide how to do it. Praise God I never did, but I understand what they. ( we) are feeling. I’ve tried to explain the thought process to others who have never lived through it, but most cannot comprehend.

  4. For all who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God. – Romans 8:14

    The Amish are not the only ones who consider suicide unpardonable. I’m not sure why so many are cruel to fellow sons of God. I don’t know why so many don’t believe judgment is reserved for God. After all, Jesus could easily have escaped the cross, but instead committed what we today call “suicide by cop.”

    And the King shall answer and say unto them, Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me. Matthew 25:40

    1. We don’t have a title yet, Charlene, but thank you for asking. I’ll have more info about it here on the blog in the coming months.

  5. Such a sensitive and thoughtful analysis. I love how you described the journals as being ‘alive’ and you are so right about being kind. It is so important. Peace and light. Dolly xx

  6. “Then she walked into a lake, and they found her nine months later.”

    This has been lurking in the back of my mind for a couple of days now, and it seems that her lake had a gestational period of nine months, same as for cow or countess.

    The scientist in me keeps telling me that it’s just synchronicity, but I want to believe it was God’s message to those who mourn her that He had enveloped her in His loving arms, that she had received those colorful wings she had depicted.

  7. Awesome Steve.

    Thanks for the piece too. I’ve often said the same thing about it being the most selfish thing one could do and truth be told I’ve looked at suicide as an option in the past and that’s one of the things I did not want to let ‘win’.

    I had an extended family member recently take his life and I could not for a minute think that he did it out of selfishness. He would have Never done that to his close nephew, sisters, brother, parents or his extended family. He was too caring and sweet.

    What I now believe is that the mind, tainted by the mental health condition, is directing the show, the genuine person or soul of us being the spectator. The fact that this young woman saw peace on the horizon was really touching. God Bless her and her family.

    1. Jerry, you speak of “selfish” as if it were a bad thing, but the flight attendant tells us to put on our own oxygen mask before we help our children with theirs. Our God makes us the steward of our own life. We are supposed to be selfish.

      As long as I can minister to the needs of others, I will. I don’t feel guilty for needing medicare and medicaid at this point, because I contributed for many years – and it’s only money. But when you’re in the throes of depression, you’re an emotional black hole, sucking up all the love and hope within your Schwarzschild radius – and as a result, people flee you, for their own survival. When it becomes unbearable, it’s time to talk to your God about going home. If he has a better idea, he’ll let yu know.

Comments are closed.